Service Change: NYC, Part 2 – the E, the 6, and the Q

I did a Service Change about the New York subway 6 line over a year ago. I had taken it up to the Bronx, so the train was elevated and there were some very interesting views. Unfortunately my subway experiences this trip were entirely underground, but I have much better pictures of the trains and such.

Firstly, there’s the E. We wanted to go up to the MET (on the east side) from our hotel (on the west side). Now, anyone who’s ever been to New York knows that going across town is a pain in the butt. The blocks are way too far apart walking, the traffic and traffic lights are horrible driving, and there aren’t many subway lines that go across. But, we were staying very close to a station on the E which does go across town, so that was very convenient.

The station was 34th Street-Penn Station, and it was what most New York subway stations are: utilitarian. It was functional and efficient, but very unattractive. For one of the city’s two railway hubs, it was surprising to see that the entrances were just as standard as any other New York subway entrance. We decided to purchase MetroCards rather than single ride fares, since MetroCards offer fares that are 25 cents cheaper ($2.50 for both bus and subway). There is a 1 dollar surcharge for getting a new card (a good way for some extra profit – take note, MBTA), but you make it back in four rides.

Heading into the station.
The ticket area, looking very bleak.
These clocks weren’t particularly useful.
The ticket barrier.
A ticket machine. “…Why wait?”
The equally bleak looking platform area.
Expect to see a lot of these…
The inside.
The destination boards were fairly standard.
A decent picture of the M, which we didn’t actually ride.
And another.

We got off at Lexington Avenue to transfer over to the 6. Once we left the platform, the station was actually kinda nice. There was an art mural, then a very modern concourse connecting to the 6.

A cool art mural.
This was a nice concourse.
The platform for the 6.
What is this? Really?
The 6 coming into the platform.
The inside.
It had a cool map letting you know where you are. The MBTA wants to put these in the new Red and Orange Line trains.
A nice mosaic station name.

The best picture I could get of the countdown clocks…
That same standard subway entrance.

The next day, we walked down High Line Park (there will be a post about that at some point) and ended up in Union Square. We had to get back to the bus before it left, and needed a direct way of getting to 34th Street or so. I suggested taking the Q, since that’s an express train and goes to 34th Street from Union Square without stopping. It was really fast! We got to 34th Street in about 3 minutes. Amazing.

No, I’m not advertizing Dawn of the Planet of the Apes. I wanted to show the convenient delay screens they have outside some stations.
Okay, that entrance is pretty cool.
The turnstiles were kind of annoying.
The concourse of Union Square.
Another blur-fest.
A different version of the electronic map.
34th Street Station.
Seems like all the decent pictures are of trains I didn’t actually take.

There won’t be another post for a week or so, as I’m going to Toronto! There’s still some New York stuff I have to do, but that’ll have to wait until I’m done with Toronto’s transit system.

Service Change: NYC, Part 1 – The Go Bus

Yes, I know I promised the new “Diary of a Bus Adventurer” post and a plethora of bus reviews, but I happened to be in New York for the past two days. I ended up taking quite a bit of transportation there, though, and I have a few Service Change posts in the works.
First we have the Go Bus. This was reviewed in a guest post way back when, and now I’ve gotten the opportunity to ride it. It boarded in the grim Alewife busway, and then we were off. The bus only makes one stop, at Riverside, and then zooms all the way to New York. Well, I say zooms. The ride back took about 7 hours due to traffic. Next time we’re taking the train…

For a much more interesting account of the Go Bus, check the old guest post.

The bus at the Alewife busway.
This looks very trippy…
Lovely air freshener…
The bus in New York.

104 (Malden Center Station – Sullivan Square Station via Ferry Street and Broadway)

The surprisingly high number of routes going between Malden Center and Wellington/Sullivan have never struck me as being particularly noteworthy. Some of them are unique: the 105 with its crazy Newland Street Housing route or the 97 for its Gateway Center detour. But the majority of them are just standard local routes, and the 104 is one of them.

We started out going over the Alford Street bridge, just like the 105. Then it became Broadway and we went through the industrial wasteland/disgustingly large parking lot area. But instead of heading up Main Street like the 105, we continued down Broadway through a mostly residential area. But soon we reached Everett Square, which had a bunch of cute small businesses.

The fairly nice view from the Alford Street bridge.

After that there was a pleasant mixture of houses and businesses. Eventually we turned onto Ferry Street, which is the unique portion of the route. After a fairly tall building (called Glendale Towers according to the bus announcement), it became a nice residential neighborhood. There was a school at the intersection with Cross Street (and the 105) and then businesses started to appear again.

Literally five blocks later we intersected with the 105 again (remember how I said that 105 route is really circuitous?) then we headed up Main Street. We turned onto Florence Street, the buildings now taller in Malden Center. Florence Street curved to the left, and we pulled into the Malden Center busway.

The 104 in Malden.

Route: 104 (Malden Center Station – Sullivan Square Station via Ferry Street and Broadway)

Ridership: A healthy amount of people rode the bus: about 30. Obviously no one went from beginning to end, but many people just used it as a feeder to the Orange Line. Based on my experiences on the 104 and 105, it seems like that’s what these Malden Center to Wellington/Sullivan routes are for.

Pros: Seems like a lot of people on Ferry Street use the bus, as this is very well-used. 30 people on a Saturday is pretty good. Some aspects of this bus’s schedule are great: every 15 minutes during rush hour is awesome, and every 30-35 minutes on Saturdays isn’t bad.

Cons: Unfortunately it’s every 40 minutes during the day, which is awful, and every 60-65 minutes nights and Sundays. Also, I noticed that heading into Malden, a number of routes take a really circuitous path through the center, the 104 included. It’s not like anyone used the weird route we took, but heading out of Malden on the 105 using the more direct Center Street, there were a bunch of people waiting! I feel that the buses should use Center Street going both ways instead of the current loop situation.

Nearby and Noteworthy: Everett Square seemed to be the nicest area along the route.

Final Verdict: 6/10
There have been a lot of mediocre routes lately… The main issue I have with the 104 is just that the weekday, night, and Sunday schedules are pretty bad. A fair amount of people used the bus on a Saturday. This doesn’t affect the final verdict for this specific bus (it would probably detract from Malden Center Station’s score when I get around to reviewing it), but the route it and its counterparts take in the center is pretty weird. Once again, I think they should just go down Center Street both ways.

Latest MBTA News: Service Updates
In blog news, I’m thinking about starting a new type of post called “Diary of a Bus Adventurer.” It would basically be about what happens between the actual bus rides, because there are some interesting things that happen aside from the buses themselves. I’m taking some buses today, so maybe I’ll try a trial post.

105 (Malden Center Station – Sullivan Square Station via Newland Street Housing)

Let me be clear right from the start: never take this bus from beginning to end. No one in their right mind would use this bus (which takes about a half hour in total) to get from Malden Center to Sullivan when the train can do it in a few minutes. So basically, don’t try this at home. With that out of the way, let’s take a ride on the 105.

I have no idea what’s going on with the destination board in this picture.

Leaving Malden Center, we headed down Center Street and picked up a fair amount of people at the very first stop, in front of a huge Super Stop and Shop (what makes it “super” I have no idea). Center Street became Eastern Ave, which was one of those neighborhoods with way too many auto shops and parking lots. Then we got to the really crazy part. Ready? Right turn on Bryant Street, left turn on Lyme Street, left turn on Willow Street, right turn on Bowdoin Street, right turn on Newland Street, right turn back onto Bryant Street, left turn on Cross Street. Wow.

I had been wondering what the Newland Street Housing was, and my assumption was confirmed: a development where all the houses are exactly the same. But many of the people on the bus got off here, and this is the only route to serve the neighborhood. There were also a few people who got on to go to Sullivan, and then we carried on.

If you ever take the 105 you’ll see a lot of these.

We then went down Cross Street, which was a nice residential street (for a change). There was a school at one point, but it was mostly just houses. We turned onto Main Street, which was a nice cross between residential and cute little businesses. It was like this for a while, with no one getting on or off the bus, and we soon got to a huge rotary. We headed onto Broadway, which was another neighborhood with grotesquely large parking lots. However, we did go by an MBTA bus yard, which was pretty cool. I could see a few really old buses, as well as an experimental bus not used in actual service.

A really bad picture, but you get the idea.

Broadway became Alford Street and we went by a giant factory (it was an industrial wasteland in general), then over a bridge. There was a view of the MBTA yard (see picture above), but the Boston skyline couldn’t be seen. We then made our way into the Sullivan Square busway, and we all got off into the darkness under the highway.

No garbled destination board this time.

Route: 105 (Malden Center Station – Sullivan Square Station via Newland Street Housing)

Ridership: The Newland Street Housing area was sort of a swap: people coming from Malden Center got off, and people going to Sullivan got on. The main purpose of this route is to connect the Newland Street Housing to the Orange Line. About 20-25 people rode in total on a Saturday afternoon.

Pros: Once again, this is the only route to serve the Newland Street Housing area, and it does that well. It seems to be fairly well-used by locals.

Cons: Seems like the schedule’s always a con. It’s about every 30 minutes rush hour (give or take), every 70 minutes during the day with service ending at 7:15, and every 60 minutes weekends. It’s not as terrible as other routes, but it could certainly be better. Also, if you’re in Malden Center and have to get to Main Street, don’t use the 105. Take the 99 or the 106, as they both run more often and are much MUCH more direct.

Nearby and Noteworthy: Your best bet at finding something interesting would be on Main Street or just in Malden Center. The Newland Street Housing isn’t noteworthy, that’s for sure.

Final Verdict: 5/10
Another 5. And just like the last one, this route has a purpose of serving a specific area, but its schedule drags it down. The 132’s schedule was worse, but the 105 still loses points on the crazy route it takes. Surely it could do something less…weird?

Latest MBTA News: Service Updates
Janitors on the MBTA are protesting about the planned layoffs of almost one third of the total cleaning workforce.

132 (Redstone Shopping Center – Malden Center Station)

“Redstone Shopping Center – that sounds really cool!” was my first thought when I boarded the bus. Is it as cool as it sounds? Find out as we take a trip through the heart of Stoneham on the 132

The first thing to note is that the 132 leaves from the much smaller second busway at Malden Center. Signage is so bad that I had no idea this busway even existed until I took this bus. We left the station with maybe 10 people on and headed up Summer Street. This was a residential neighborhood, and it wasn’t that nice. We turned onto Clifton Street and the neighborhood seemed to get better, then we turned onto Washington Street.

The bus in Malden.

There was a fairly large amount of people who got on at Oak Grove, then we went through an industrial wasteland-ish neighborhood. It got residential soon, though, and there were a few small businesses around Wyoming Hill Station. We turned onto West Wyoming Ave into another residential area, and then crossed Fellsway East into the wilderness.

Well, not the wilderness, but the Middlesex Falls Reservation. But it was just a forest, and we sped right through it. Suddenly I noticed some kangaroos behind a fence right by the road. After initial confusion, I realized we were going by the Stone Zoo. Literally going by – there aren’t any stops here. There was even a residential area after! But no stops.

A lovely view of Spot Pond.

We then turned onto Main Street upon exiting the reservation and started making stops again. It was a residential area, with a few businesses and a school dotted in. Soon we reached Stoneham Square, which actually seemed pretty happening. Most of the people on the bus got off here, leaving only four people. Main Street then became a haven for trashy businesses and overly large parking lots. I started to get worried about Redstone. And then, we arrived.

Yup, it’s a dump.

What was I expecting? For some reason, a legitimate mall. Anything but, it was basically a parking lot and a very mediocre store selection. But I had to hang out there for an hour until the next bus. If you want to know about how I entertained myself for all this time, check the Nearby and Noteworthy section below. Anyway, I headed back to the bus stop about 10 minutes before it was due to arrive (I’m not taking chances with hour-long headways).

The bus stop.

The stop was better than the Burlington Mall situation on the 350! There was a real bench here. A real bench! But whereas the Burlington Mall is a very popular stop, there were maybe three other people waiting here for the 132. The MBTA needs to get its stop priorities straight.

Finally!

Route: 132 (Redstone Shopping Center – Malden Center Station)

Ridership: There were maybe 20 people on the bus heading north. Most of them came on from the Orange Line, and quite a few people got off at Stoneham Square. There weren’t many that continued on to Redstone.

Pros: This route cuts right through the heart of Stoneham, and aside from the 99 (which barely goes into it anyway), this is the only bus that serves the town.

Cons: Let’s talk schedule. It’s every hour during the day, every 45 minutes during the evening (but not morning) rush, and every hour on Saturdays. There’s no service at night or on Sundays. Another note is that the bus makes no stops at all within the Middlesex Falls Reservation. I’m not sure if people would take the bus to Stone Zoo, but I feel like a stop close to it would be great, especially since there are houses nearby as well.

Nearby and Noteworthy: So what did I do at Redstone? Well, there was this weird place called The Paper Store that had a lot of different items on offer. There was a decent book section (considering the shopping center has no proper bookstore), a fair amount of toys, and lots of greeting cards. This is a Hallmark-owned store, after all.

Final Verdict: 5/10
It gets extra points for being pretty much the only bus that goes through Stoneham, but that doesn’t change the fact that it has issues. The main thing is the bad schedule, of course, but then there’s the issue of the Middlesex Falls Reservation. Is there some sort of protected land issue that prevents bus stops from being put in the area, or is there a different reason why there’s no stop for the Stone Zoo?

Latest MBTA News: Service Updates

Random Photos: Nice View?

There’s a pretty nice view of the Boston skyline from Sullivan Square. The only problem is the foreground: a dingy parking lot, a factory, and a bunch of random poles. Oh, well.

Ugh.

Random Photos: Transportation Exhibit at the Smithsonian Museum of American History

When we went to the Smithsonian Museum of American History, I just had to drag my friends to the transportation exhibit. It was fantastic, and I took a few (bad) pictures. Here they are:

An old streetcar.
The front of a bus, but not the rest.
 A replica of a Chicago EL station.
You could go inside an old EL train.
Awesome old-fashioned map!
A beautiful old steam train.

Service Change: Wilson Coach Bus and Glimpses of the D.C. Metro

As expected, we didn’t take the Metro on my school trip to Washington D.C. And I don’t really have much to say about the coach bus, since it was practically the same one as the one on the UMASS shuttle. Other than that, there’s really not much to say about the 11 hour bus ride or the few metro sightings on the trip. So here are some of the pictures I took (too many):

The bus.
The inside, looking very dark and creepy.

Stopped at a rest stop.

We made it!
An X1, apparently heading to Minnesota Avenue Station.
“Friendship Heights.” I like that.
So close…
The 11Y, I guess.
Beautiful Union Station.
A bus sign.
At one point we passed by the Department of Transportation building and I got this beautiful picture.
A bus shelter.
Whoa, serious bunching!
A bad picture of a Metro station entrance.
The stripe under the M signifies what line stops at the station, which is actually really clever.
A nice entrance to a station.
There’s a silver stripe at this station, but the Silver Line is still under construction.
Some more bunching on the 32.
The 16X.

Sorry for the disappointing post. There will be better stuff in the future, I promise!

SL4 (Dudley Station – South Station at Essex Street via Washington St)

This is the last Silver Line route to be reviewed on this blog! Huzzah! That said, the SL4 follows almost the exact same route as the SL5, and was only created to provide a connection from Dudley to the SL1 and SL2. But actually, it ended up being more useful than it might seem.

A swaggering man exits the bus at Dudley.
From Dudley, we headed up Washington Street through a pretty bad neighborhood, and soon we went into the bus lane. There were some nice parks around Melnea Cass Boulevard, then a mixture of small businesses, lovely brownstones, and tenements. There was a huge cathedral at Dartmouth Street, then the uglier buildings started to dwindle.
These views down articulated buses never get old.
We crossed over I-90, and that’s where the bus lane ended. Of course there was plenty of traffic to contend with, and the bus slowed to a crawl. The buildings got taller and taller as we went through Tufts Medical Area and Chinatown Stations. But whereas the SL5 continues down Washington Street into the theater district, we turned onto the much less crowded Essex Street. Chinatown is only served by South Station-bound buses because of the loop it makes over here.
Bus inception never gets old either.
There was barely any traffic on Essex Street, and near South Station the bus lane came back! And there was a legitimate shelter! It was amazing. There was a crowd waiting to get back on the bus, and then it looped around to head back to Dudley.
The bus outside of South Station.
Route: SL4 (Dudley Station – South Station at Essex Street via Washington St)
Ridership: Sitting in the back of an articulated bus (because come on, who wants to sit in the front), I couldn’t get an accurate ridership number. The best I can say is “a lot.”
Pros: Like the SL5, the section along Washington Street is pretty quick. And the shelters are pretty swanky, offering shelter (obviously) and countdown clocks for the buses. That said, the clocks aren’t particularly useful when buses are late:

Good to know…

But the SL4 has an advantage over its counterpart in that the trip to South Station is so much quicker than the one to Downtown Crossing! If you have to get to the Red Line from along the route, the SL4 is a better decision. Chinatown and Downtown Crossing aren’t too far apart, but the traffic along there can be really bad. The SL4 just has to breeze down Essex Street to get to South Station.

Cons: There’s still the traffic at that one area between I-90 and Chinatown, but it’s not as bad as what the SL5 has to deal with.
Nearby and Noteworthy: See the SL5 post.
Final Verdict: 8/10
Just for comparison, the SL5 got a 5. I really hated the traffic when I rode that route. The traffic can be kinda bad here, so Essex Street turned out to really speed up the journey. This bus certainly isn’t an adequate replacement for the Orange Line by any means, but it’s much better than the other route on Washington Street.
Latest MBTA News: Service Updates
I’m going to Washington D.C. for a few days on a school trip, so don’t expect any posts in the next week or so. I plan to do a Service Change on the bus that takes us there (an 11 hour drive, hooray!), but unfortunately won’t be riding the Metro. See you in a week!

Waltham

I always thought Reading would be a one-off, but here we are with another Commuter Rail station. Waltham is a Zone 2 station on the Fitchburg Line, fairly close to Boston. It’s a pretty major bus hub, which is how I got here in the first place. The area where you actually catch the buses isn’t anything special, though, just a shelter. And most of the buses that serve Waltham are weekday-only expresses. So…not that impressive.

The station itself is pretty humble, too. It’s also really weirdly laid out: the station is single-track (although it’s double on either end), with two separate platforms about a thousand feet apart from each other. One is for inbound trains, and one is for outbound. I don’t like the layout personally: I feel like trains should use the same platform, since the two seem to be pretty far apart.
One of the shelters.
The shelters are very similar to the one at Reading: cute, wooden, and high-floor. These shelters, unlike Reading, have intact “Will not clear man on side of car” signs, solving the mystery from Reading. Here in Waltham, there are individual parking lots for each, which is nice – 50 spaces in total. Both platforms have modern bus shelters too, even though trains don’t pick people up there.
A big mismatch of stuff: a parking meter, a schedule, a random wastebasket, something, and a pointless shelter.
The eastern side of the station has an interesting aspect: there’s a historic visitor’s center inside the old station building. You can get Commuter Rail tickets in there, as well as a number of brochures. At least, that’s what it looked like. I couldn’t completely tell because it was CLOSED. It was a weekday! Isn’t that when Commuter Rail tickets are most needed?
The charming building is deceiving.
There are two level crossings here, too, which are always fun. In busy downtown Waltham, there’s a huge traffic jam every time a train comes along. That said, it’s not easy (or cheap) to put the train below grade or in a tunnel. And I have lower standards for Commuter Rail stations anyway, so I’ll let Waltham off on this one.
This looks delightfully gritty.
Station: Waltham
Ridership: This station has the fourth-busiest ridership on the Fitchburg Line, according to Wikipedia, with 545 average weekday boardings. It seemed busy enough when I went.
Pros: I really like the wooden shelters, just like in Reading. The ridership seems high, too, and there are parking spaces aplenty.
Cons: I don’t like the weird single-track layout, nor do I like the fact that the visitor’s center was closed for some reason. But the fact that the two platforms are 1000 feet apart is the worst thing about this station, in my opinion.
Nearby and Noteworthy: I really wanted to see what the Charles River Museum of Industry and Innovation is like, but I wanted to catch the 170. The museum seems really interesting, though. Maybe I could’ve found out more if the visitor’s center had been open.
Final Verdict: 6/10
Both Reading and Waltham have really quaint shelters, there’s no denying that. But whereas Waltham has two that are pretty far apart, Reading only has one which is why I gave it a 9. But Waltham’s two platform layout is just really annoying to me! Why not just use one to alleviate confusion? Also, that visitor’s center really should’ve been open. Really.
Latest MBTA News: Service Updates
Nothing much has happened, but the MBTA did put this interesting article on their website about the person who does all the automatic announcements, Frank Oglesby.

Nubian

This post was written back when this station was called Dudley, but I’ve changed the title to make it more easily searchable from the blog.

In Greek mythology, the Labyrinth was built to hold the Minotaur, a half man, half bull creature. The Labyrinth was so complicated and confusing that even the builder barely escaped after finishing it. Frankly, though, I think they could’ve just as easily trapped the Minotaur in Dudley Station.

Yes, this bus hub is pretty darn big. So big, in fact, that it’s extremely hard to find anything there! It has five “platforms” in two separate buildings with 20 berths in total! It’s hard to make 20 berths easy to navigate, but luckily there are “Dudley Station Bus Finders” infrequently spaced around the station. They don’t tell you where you are, and are even outdated. Fantastic.

Not a great photo, but you can see how complicated it is.

But I can’t go ranting on about how annoyingly complicated this place is, as there are some good things about it. For one thing, there are a lot of buses serving Dudley. There are 18 in total, but three of them have very limited service. Five of the routes are Key Bus Routes, plus there are the two Silver Line routes serving the station. Servicewise, this station is fantastic. And there are bus countdown clocks here, but I didn’t check to see if they worked or not.

The interior of one of the buildings.

Also, the station architecture is fantastic. As you may or may not know, the Orange Line used to have an elevated station here on its old alignment. When building the bus station, they actually used elements from the original, making for a very cool, old-fashioned look. The buildings definitely provide adequate shelter from the elements, too. I noticed a would-be convenient building with CharlieCard machines in it, but the door was padlocked. I know it’s not the nicest area, but people have to refill their cards…

One of the buildings.

Digital clocks like you would see in the subway are littered around the station as well, though I don’t see much use for them. There are also random trash bins scattered about, but the station isn’t very clean. I also want to point out that it was the middle of the day and there were a million lights on in the station. As you can see in the picture below, the station is both open and has a glass ceiling (one of them has a glass ceiling, the other has windows up near the roof). The lights look nice, but they’re completely useless during the day. Save some energy, MBTA.

The inside of one of the buildings.
Station: Dudley
Ridership: It can be pretty busy here, even if it’s not a “legit” station. After all, five Key Bus Routes converge here, as well as a plethora of other routes. Plus there’s the Silver Line, which sort of acts as a feeder to downtown from here.
Pros: This is a huge bus hub, and most of the buses here have pretty good schedules. I also really like the architecture; the fact that one of the buildings uses elements from the original elevated station is a nice touch.
Cons: This station is too darn confusing! There are a million berths, there are two buildings, and the “station finders” are ridiculous. If they could at least update the maps to be relevant today (the ones up now are from 2007, and are “good until superseded” – yeah, right) and show where the viewer is, it would be great! The station would still be a mess, but at least it would make navigation a little easier.
Nearby and Noteworthy: Frankly, I don’t like being in the neighborhood around Dudley. I’m sure there’s some very nice stuff around there, but I wouldn’t know.
Final Verdict: 6/10
This station was originally going to get a much lower score, but I realized that there are some good qualities to it. Namely, there are a lot of buses that serve this station, and its architecture is really nice. Of course, it’s still really complicated, and the maps are out of date and overly confusing. It all evens out to slightly worse than average.
Latest MBTA News: Service Updates
Fare hikes are almost upon us. They’re not that bad, luckily. Click here for more information.