SRTA: FR 2 (North Main)
The 2 turned out to be a dastardly one to ride. Earlier in the day, Sam and I had tried to get it from its Shaw’s terminus to ride it around its long terminus loop, but it had left Shaw’s early. Surprise. I had to grab it later from the Fall River Terminal instead.
We headed out from the terminal and made our way over I-195, eventually coming onto North Main Street. I was surprised – most of Fall River had been underwhelming, but this little strip on North Main was actually kinda charming. There wasn’t even much in the buildings on either side, but there were these nice trees that made it feel a lot more welcoming. I guess that goes to show how far greenery goes in improving the urban landscape.
It started to get residential soon, with some dense but nice suburban houses lining the road. There were also a few businesses, particularly around the intersection with President Ave (also the location of a school and a park). On weekdays, there’s an extra deviation here that runs to a place called Commonwealth Landing. It seems like it’s meant to serve Bristol Community College, but there are also some apartments there.
The street became a big mix of stuff after that. We went by a cemetery, then there were houses, businesses, and some factories converted to modern uses. Crossing over Route 79, a highway, we got closer to the Taunton River and it was almost all suburban houses for a while. That changed when we pulled into the route’s last stop, Riverview Marketplace – or, as the SRTA calls it in the schedule, “Shaw’s”.
Except it’s not actually the last stop, it’s just where I got off. When you’re reviewing every bus route on the system in a day, you need to make some cuts, especially if the route screwed you over beforehand! The rest of the 2 consists of a big loop, running clockwise or counterclockwise depending on the time of day. It was the morning in this case, so the bus would have made its way onto Airport Road, running through (and deviating into) an industrial area. It would then turn onto Innovation Way, which is all woods aside from an Amazon facility, which also gets a deviation. Finally, now in Freetown, the bus would have turned back onto Main Street, going past some apartment complexes – one called Four Winds gets a deviation – before returning to Shaw’s.
SRTA Route: FR 2 (North Main)
Ridership: For the SRTA, this route gets great ridership, with about 508 people per day in May 2014. In fact, this is the busiest bus route in Fall River. We’ll see why this fact annoys me once we start talking about the schedule…
Pros: The 2 takes a nice, direct route as far north as Shaw’s. The Commonwealth Landing deviation on weekdays is pretty annoying, but it’s a really pedestrian-unfriendly area, so I understand why they do it. On weekdays, the route runs every half hour from 6 AM to 9 PM – pretty darn good.
Cons: But on Saturdays, it’s every hour! Why? They run half-hourly Saturday service on other routes that get far less ridership than the 2! Also, there’s this twice-daily deviation to “Holmes Apartments” that just complicates the route. I think the residents of Holmes Apartments can stand to walk five minutes to the main route, and then we don’t need this random deviation to just make the route more complicated. Finally, I’m mad that it left Shaw’s early, but at least we had cut it really close so it didn’t feel as cruel as the 9.
Nearby and Noteworthy: This route serves a ton, actually! First, there’s the Children’s Museum of Greater Fall River, which seems like a nice little place for little kids. There’s also the Fall River Fire Museum, which isn’t open to the public “as of yet”, but it’s run by some very dedicated people and they seem to open up for the occasional event. Finally, the loop at the northern end of the route serves part of the Freetown-Fall River State Forest. It looks like it has some beautiful trails with stunning views!
Final Verdict: 6/10
I can’t get over the hourly Saturday service. The busiest route in Fall River only runs every hour on weekends! That’s just crazy to me! Also, this is a prime route for Sunday service if the SRTA ever adds that, which they absolutely should. The Holmes Apartments deviation is also annoying, and in general, this route makes a ton of deviations (particularly on the loop section). That all adds up to a final score of a 6/10 – it’s a good route otherwise!
Latest MBTA News: Service Updates
Atlantic City
Considering that it only gets twelve trains per day (or, at the moment, zero trains per day), five-track Atlantic City Station is surprisingly legit. According to ol’ Wikipedia, it was built in 1989, which makes the size of the station all the more surprising. Service was awful then, too, when Amtrak was running the line, so…yeah, that makes this an interesting one!
I have very little to say about the station platforms. They’re at a level of barebones that’s just tolerable enough to not affect the overall quality of the station, but on the other hand, they sure aren’t winning any beauty contests, especially with the rotting shelters above. Also, it’s a good thing there are so many tracks here, since this station basically doubles as the AC Line’s yard. If NJT needs to do minor repairs on trains, there are actually facilities here that let them do it.
“Seating for Ticketed Customers Only. Two-Hour Time Limit.” Oh, NJT, you never change, do you? Well, folks, you heard it here first: NO SITTING ON THE UNCOMFORTABLE GRATED BENCHES UNLESS YOU HAVE A TICKET. Luckily, you can purchase tickets here at either a few vending machines or the staffed ticket offices, which are apparently open 5:30 AM to 9 PM, seven days a week! That’s impressive. Also of note is the flipboard showing arrivals and departures, although never any origin or destination other than “Philadelphia”.
There are a few other attractions in the rather austere waiting area. One is “ESQUIRES II”, a deli that I can find next to no information about online. I will say that it has very nice seating! The station also has a small parking garage with 75 spaces, and they’re apparently free to ticketed passengers. I don’t know if it doubles as convention center parking or not, but still, I can’t complain about free parking (and no, you don’t get a “jackpot” for landing on it. All that does is make the game even longer than it already is! You know it takes place in Atlantic City, right?).
But wait, there’s more! Atlantic City also has bathrooms (not particularly bad or good, so not much to say there), an information stand with bus schedules, and a “food court” whose fancy neon sign betrays the fact that it’s really just a few vending machines. Maybe “ESQUIRE II” is considered part of the food court as well.
I alluded to this a little bit before, but Atlantic City Station is part of the same complex as the city’s convention center. As such, there is a direct doorway between the two, while the exit takes you out to the grand (well, maybe not grand, but big) entrance to the facility. There are a few free jitney routes to all the casinos in the city, but if you’re not getting on those, it’s a 13-minute walk down to the boardwalk. Oh, this entrance also has two giant, clunky bike racks that have probably been here since 1989. That’s right: space for four whole bikes!
NJT Station: Atlantic City
Ridership: Interestingly, this is the busiest stop on the Atlantic City Line, with 594 boardings per weekday. That beats out Philadelphia, the second-busiest station, which only gets 489 people per day. It does make sense, though (see my AC Line post for why), and I’ll bet ridership is comprable or even higher on the weekend, especially in the summer.
Pros: This is a very functional terminal. It doesn’t have the grandeur of, say, Philadelphia 30th Street on the other end of the line, but it still has great amenities and services: a big waiting room, ticket offices, and a few options for food. The free jitney shuttles are a fantastic bonus, too, although it has to be said that you’re basically guaranteed to lose money once you leave their casino destinations. In that sense, it would just be cruel to charge for the jitneys.
Cons: Not too much, actually. The platforms look old, as I mentioned, but you’re not gonna be spending a lot of time on them. The location could also be better, but the jitney shuttles do make up for that, and a 13 minute walk to the boardwalk isn’t bad.
Nearby and Noteworthy: If you’re visiting Atlantic City, you’re here for the beach, the casinos, or both. The city offers plenty of each.
Final Verdict: 8/10
Yeah, no real complaints here! It’s too bad that rail service isn’t operating to the station right now, but as it sits there gathering dust (or sand – that tends to accumulate on the tracks), we can at least look at it and say, “Hey. You’re a good station, Atlantic City.” Nice.
Latest SEPTA News: Service Updates
I’ve finally set up a subscribe by email option! Check out the main page if you want to get an email whenever I post.
SRTA: FR 8 (BCC/Durfee HS)
Time for a short route that’s not particularly noteworthy. Okay, it’s the FR 8!
We left the parking lot of Bristol Community College and turned onto Elsbree Street, which soon passed Durfee High School. There were some suburban businesses as we turned onto President Ave, but it got residential when we swung around onto a roundabout to Eastern Ave, then turned onto New Boston Road. Apart from where we intersected the 4 at Robeson Street, it was mostly dense houses along here.
We made our way around the giant Charlton Memorial Hospital via local roads before settling on Linden Street. This is the unfortunate part of the route where, due to one-ways and narrow roads, the inbound route is three blocks away from the outbound. Once Linden Street ended, we did some quick turns to get onto Bedford Street, and this led us into downtown Fall River. It was only a short time from there before we got to the terminal.
SRTA Route: FR 8 (BCC/Durfee HS)
Ridership: The 8 tends to get higher ridership during school months and less ridership when school is off. For example, in April 2014, the route got about 420 passengers per day (probably more on weekdays and less on Saturdays), but in June of that year, it only got about 283 people per day.
Pros: The 8 serves two major schools, a huge hospital, and dense residential areas. It’s also pretty direct, and it runs frequently, with service every half hour on weekdays until around 9 PM. Saturday service is only every hour, but I think ridership is a lot lower on Saturdays anyway – my midday inbound trip got just one person.
Cons: Mostly just the inbound-outbound split in the middle of the route. I know there’s no way to fix that, but three blocks is not an insignificant distance. Also, there’s a slight typo on the schedule where a school trip serving Durfee High School shows up after a regular trip, even though the school one comes first. Not a huge deal, but a little annoying.
Nearby and Noteworthy: Nothing much, unless you believe in the importance of a good education. Two schools, people! Two!
Final Verdict: 7/10
Yup, this is just a standard, quick little route. I don’t have too much to say – I think the 8 does what it sets out to do pretty well. Even the lack of Sunday service isn’t as big of a deal for this one, since a lot of its destinations are weekday-oriented anyway.
Latest MBTA News: Service Updates
Requiem for the Atlantic City Line
“Beginning Wednesday, September 5 and continuing until early 2019, NJ TRANSIT will continue the installation of Positive Train Control (PTC) equipment on our rail fleet throughout the state. To accommodate this critical safety upgrade, all service on the Atlantic City Rail Line (ACRL) will be temporarily suspended beginning Wednesday, September 5.”
These were frightening words to a lot of people. With no definitive start date for service, how do we know NJT isn’t going to just shut down the whole line entirely? Well, I think there’s nothing to worry about – it will open up again eventually. But while it is closed, let’s take a look at the line as a whole and discuss its pros and cons. What was good about it, and what can be improved when it opens up again?
For those who don’t know, the Atlantic City Line is New Jersey Transit’s only commuter rail line in South Jersey, and the only one that doesn’t go to New York. It begins at Philadelphia’s 30th Street Station and, by way of many different environments and towns, ends up “down the shore” at Atlantic City Station. A few friends and I rode the line on the last weekend of service, and it was one of the most dynamic and interesting commuter rail lines I’ve ever ridden.
Coming from UPenn, I’m within reasonable walking distance of 30th Street Station, which is a good thing, since that’s the only Philadelphia station that the AC Line leaves from. This is already a turnoff for some people – of the three main stations in Philly, 30th Street is the least central. Of course, it’s also the only place in Philly that Amtrak stops, and that gets a ton of riders, so clearly people are willing to use the hub. The AC Line’s diesel trains couldn’t go down into the Regional Rail tunnel through Philly, anyway.
Speaking of Amtrak, the AC Line actually boards from the beautiful Amtrak section of 30th Street. Once the awesome flip board displayed our train’s track number, we headed down to the lower level of the station. The train arrived, bell ringing, a few minutes later.
This train was one of twelve that would operate every day. There’s really no rhyme or reason to the schedule, with gaps as short as 50 minutes or as long as 3 and a half hours. The nature of the line is interesting, too – it has very few rush hour trips to and from Philadelphia, and demand runs in both directions. Some people definitely use the line to commute, but a ton of leisure riders use it too.
Let’s also talk about the fares, because they’re interesting. A full trip from Philadelphia to Atlantic City costs $10.75 – a lot to ask, but expected for NJT. The thing is, though, if you take PATCO to Lindenwold and hop on the train from there, it will only cost you $8.25, including the $3 PATCO fare. “But Miles, surely that takes longer!” NO. As you’ll soon see, even with the transfer time, that itinerary gets you to Philadelphia faster than the train, plus you end up right in Center City instead of at 30th Street! Incidentally, the cheapest journey you could make on the AC Line is between the last two stops, Absecon and Atlantic City, and it costs just a buck fifty. A monthly pass for that journey is a mere $44!
And now, it was time for the absolute worst part of the AC Line. The section from Philadelphia to Lindenwold was and always will be a total slog, mainly because of the crazy route the train has to take. The most convenient rail connection in the direction of Atlantic City from 30th Street happens to go all the way up to North Philadelphia. Here, just look how frustrating the route is compared to PATCO:
But that’s the route we had to use, so we were going to use it. It takes over 20 minutes just to get to the first stop, and during that time, you’re just chugging along past vacant apartments and huge old industrial buildings. There’s one bit where the track runs under the El and you think “Oh, why can’t there just be a transfer here?” when you see the Market Frankford Line flying above.
Finally, the track rises onto the disgusting old Delair Bridge over the Delaware River. There seems to always be something wrong with this bridge when it opens for boats, and whenever something goes wrong, train service is instantly terminated. I had actually planned to ride the AC Line once before, but nope, the bridge was stuck open. No trains! I hope they make some improvements on this rusting piece of junk while the line is closed, but it doesn’t seem like that’s planned.
The Pennsauken Transit Center station is right after the bridge. This is a newer station, built to facilitate transfers to the River LINE light rail service. After that and a short industrial section, you’re travelling through suburbia for a while. In fact, Cherry Hill Station is located right behind a shopping plaza! Also, we saw the 340 rail replacement bus here for some reason. Uh…NJT, trains were still operating at this point!
Just east of Westmont, the line joins up with PATCO and they run together until Lindenwold. The sad thing is that on the way back, we ended up next to a PATCO train, and even making stops…PATCO was still faster. I guess they don’t call it the “speedline” for nothing. The parking lot hellscape of Lindenwold was our next stop, and from there, it would be just the AC Line again.
The scenery isn’t too different after Lindenwold – just more suburban residential areas and some bits of forest. Soon after crossing a road with some businesses and parking lots, we went by the old Berlin Station, now just sitting unused in the middle of a neighborhood. Instead, we stopped at Atco, a station whose surroundings consist of: a parking lot, woods, a motel, woods, a mobile home manufacturer, woods, and also woods. About a mile east from the station was downtown Atco, which I guess didn’t have enough room for a parking lot to “justify” putting the station there. It was a pretty barren downtown, admittedly.
There’s not much to report for the section past Atco. For a while, the train just runs through the forest, occasionally going parallel to streets in increasingly rural residential neighborhoods. Interestingly, the streets it parallels are always called Atlantic Ave. Maybe there was a continuous road at some point? We also passed occasional tracts of farmland.
Those farms marked the beginning of what I call the “Nebraska” section of the line. Its characteristics include flat land, the aforementioned farms, and the town of Hammonton, which feels like it was pulled straight out of the midwest. About half a mile east of the downtown is Hammonton Station, which was built with a long, skinny parking lot alongside it.
There’s an industrial section after Hammonton, but that doesn’t mean the scenery is boring. Indeed, we went by a bunch of dangerous-looking vehicles stored behind a National Guard office, and that was right after passing a statue factory with a huge lot of its goods on display! From that point, the scenery can best be described by what this infamous map of New Jersey calls it: “ghetto in the woods”. Yeah…that’s pretty accurate.
The track is on a complete and utter straightaway for a while, including for the next stop, which has to be one of my favorite train station names ever: Egg Harbor City. Despite the promising title, though, the town is unremarkable, and it’s gone soon after departing the stop. There was a long stretch of forest from there, broken only by a panoramic view of the Atlantic City International Airport, and later on, the city’s reservoir.
Civilization was reached in the form of suburban development along White Horse Pike. About when that started to appear, we made our second-to-last stop, Absecon. Again, there wasn’t much to see here. The station did mark the end of the seemingly endless straightaway, and we started to curve south after our stop. Woods continued until suddenly, we broke out into a vast expanse of marshland.
The Atlantic City skyline was constantly in view as we sped over the flat plains. The track came up next to the Atlantic City Expressway, and we started to slow down. We crawled over the swing bridge that crosses over a river, and right after that is a level crossing with essentially a highway. Finally, right after that, we arrived at the Atlantic City train station.
So that’s the train ride. Or, I guess, that was the train ride. You can see why this is a desirable way to get down the shore: the train is comfortable, and there’s a ton to see during the trip. However, now that the train isn’t running, the alternative options of getting to Atlantic City have taken the spotlight. Let’s look at those.
There are a number of buses that are redundant to the AC Line, most of which feed into Lindenwold. As far as Atlantic City trips go, the 340 is an express from there to Lindenwold, but that’s only a temporary route for the duration of the closure; the 554, on the other hand, acts as a local alternative to the train, serving every stop and much more. That one has always existed, and it is far slower than riding the rails. In fact, the train is practically unbeatable from Atlantic City to Lindenwold, and it takes about the same amount of time as driving!
I’m more concerned about Lindenwold to Philly, which is over a third of the whole AC Line journey. This is where the train is really problematic – when you get to Lindenwold, you think you’re getting close because it’s the end of the PATCO, but there’s still another 40-odd minutes to go before Philly. Like I said before, PATCO is faster than the train from there to Center City.
But why not just eliminate the transfer? NJT has the bus for you: the 551, which existed before and will exist after the closure, is an express bus from the Philadelphia Greyhound Terminal to the Atlantic City Bus Terminal. Both of those places are closer to their respective towns’ activity centers, and the bus is scheduled to be slightly faster than the train (yes, traffic may change the actual running time)! Where it really beats out the rail line, though, is frequency: the 551 runs every hour or better, plus it runs 24/7 service. Best of all, rail tickets are cross-honored on the 551, so it costs the exact same amount as the train.
I think this commuter quote from this article explains it best: “I wouldn’t be surprised if a lot of people (stay with the bus in January), because the train always had delays and stuff like that anyway.” That’s the unfortunate truth: in many ways, the bus is simply better than the train. That’s not to say the train is bad, and I really did enjoy my ride, but I see a ton of advantages to using the bus, from frequency and span to not having to use the awful rail bridge over the Delaware River.
Still, summer traffic to resort locations is awful. The train ride is a ton of fun. The line truly is speedy from AC to Lindenwold. It’s ultimately up to you how you want to spend your journey to the shore, and hopefully, the choice will be made available once the train opens up again in early 2019. Assuming it opens on schedule. Which it probably won’t. But maybe it will. I dunno. We’ll see.
SRTA: FR 14 (Swansea Mall)
It’s time to go west! Leave the constraints of Fall River and escape to the idyllic countryside of Swansea! It’s home to such wonderful points of interest as, and this is a direct quote from Wikipedia, “Swansea Motor Inn (featuring water beds)”! Featuring water beds? Sounds like a great place to me! Let’s hop on the 14 and head out there!
“Are you Max?” the driver asked. “No, I’m Miles,” I responded. “Then you can’t take pictures of the buses,” the driver said. “Only Max can take pictures.” Welp, looked like I wouldn’t be getting a photo of the 14. Shoulda just said my name was Max, it’s close enough! The bus, with its picture having not been taken, headed up 4th Street, crossing I-195. As soon as we made it to the other side of the highway, we turned onto Pleasant Street and then hopped onto a ramp to get onto it.
We zoomed through the short tunnel underneath Fall River City Hall, then the highway headed onto the impressively high Braga Bridge over the Taunton River. Taking the first exit on the other side of the bridge in Somerset, we merged onto Wilbur Ave, a street offering a mix of houses, woods, and farmland. It curved north, passing the Clifton Rehab Center, and some suburban businesses dotted the road as we got closer to the river.
We used a roundabout to get onto Riverside Ave, but we were only on it for a few seconds before turning onto Slades Ferry Road (right across the street from an abandoned bridge). Among the sights to see were suburban businesses and what is apparently a park and ride – I imagine it has to be for this route, since there are no other buses here, but there’s no indication of its existence anywhere on the route schedule or the SRTA website. We used Brayton Ave to get onto Grand Army of the Republic Highway next.
G.A.R. Highway was a very very very wide road that was near-impossible to cross, so I suppose the route’s Stop & Shop deviation was inevitable. After that deviation, though, we went up Brayton Point Road, a pleasant residential street. Read Street, which we turned onto, was similar, but we soon headed down Lees River Ave to return to G.A.R. Highway. It was at least slightly narrower as we took it over the Lees River, entering Swansea.
The road had a brief stint in the woods before the retail came back, and when it did, we performed an outbound-only deviation to Target. Next, we turned onto Swansea Mall Drive and did another outbound-only deviation, this time to Swansea Crossing. Finally, we looped around into the parking lot for the dying Swansea Mall, making a stop in between the mall and Walmart. Contrary to what Google Maps says, the bus doesn’t actually deviate into the Walmart, which created a lot of confusion when it came to Sam finding me in order to pick me up.
SRTA Route: 14 (Swansea Mall)
Ridership: As you might expect from a suburban bus route, overall ridership on the 14 is low (187 people per day in May 2014) and cost per rider is high ($10.77 in the same month). However, this was one of the routes of the day where I saw the highest number of people on board at once: 11 people leaving the terminal. This is probably because, as a suburban route, the 14 is bound to get less local ridership and more people coming from Fall River.
Pros: This is the one connection to Somerset and Swansea, and the route generally serves the biggest locations in each town. It’s only every hour, but because the route is longer than others, it makes sense from an efficiency standpoint to run it less frequently. Also, it makes up for the low frequency with a large span of service, with buses running until 9 PM on weekdays.
Cons: I don’t know if commuting into Fall River is a common thing, but because the route doesn’t start until 9 AM, it’s impossible to commute with the 14. The route is also pretty crazy, and it felt maddening when I was on board. Now that I look at the map, though, the deviations make sense – these are just spread-out places, and it’s hard to serve everything well with just one route. The outbound-only ones are all close enough to the end that it’s basically treated as a loop.
Nearby and Noteworthy: If you get off at Swansea Crossing, it’s just a 15-minute walk to the SWANSEA MOTOR INN! WATER BEDS, BABY!!!!! No, there really isn’t much to see along here. If you like dying or dead malls, though, it might be worth checking out the Swansea Mall, since it’s definitely on its way down.
Final Verdict: 6/10
Y’know, it’s a suburban route, and it does its best. There’s a lot to serve in these towns, and if you can only afford to run one route, you’re gonna end up with something a little crazy. It still gets people, and it’s nice that it runs pretty late into the night.
Latest MBTA News: Service Updates
40th Street Portal (Trolleys)
Today was the grand opening of the Trolley Portal Gardens, so it’s a perfect time to do our review of the 40th Street Portal trolley station! I attended the opening ceremony on behalf of the SEPTA Youth Advisory Council, and it was a great time. Among the speakers were the Mayor of Philadelphia and the General Manager of SEPTA, and there was a proper ribbon cutting with big novelty scissors! After the ribbon cutting, the Trolley Car Diner offered free food and a SEPTA booth had some fantastic swag.
So what’s new here at 40th Street? Basically, over the course of almost eight years, a number of collaborating city groups have taken a space that looked like this and transformed it into a really nice public garden. There are multicolored seats, a bunch of different trees, and even a restaurant – let’s talk about that first.
I don’t know if the Trolley Car Station restaurant really counts as part of the review or not, but it played a big role in this event, so why not? First of all, the atmosphere both inside and outside is fantastic: the outside has nice couches and tables where people can sit, the first floor consists of a long high table and a bar, and the upper floor has booth style seating and an awesome mural. The menu is a little weird for my tastes, but I’m sure a ton of people will like this place. Plus, it has great transit access, obviously!
Okay, but I’m Miles in Transit – I care about the station. The gardens have extended into the station itself, and it’s beautiful. The layout here is slightly wonky, but not too hard to figure out: basically, the outbound 34 stops at the northern shelter, the outbound 11, 13, and 36 stop at the next shelter, and all the inbounds stop at the southernmost platform. I love that all the inbounds stop at the same place, so you don’t have to play the guessing game of which route will come first.
Okay, here’s something annoying: the most direct path to the inbound platform is technically illegal to walk on; a big sign tells you not to do it. Here’s the problem with that: the real path is more roundabout, and though it’s nice walking through the garden on this charming twisty path, I just want to catch the train. Needless to say, I have seen many people just use the illegal way, and honestly, no one seems to care. Just look to make sure a trolley isn’t coming.
As for the places where you actually get the train, they’re quite good! There isn’t much to each shelter, but there doesn’t have to be – each one has a long concrete bench, a wastebasket, an LED sign that doesn’t tell you anything important, and some maps and information. Each one also has the dreaded blue light, signalling that trolleys are doing their Sunday night diversion to 40th and Market.
I’ll briefly talk about the entrances, although there isn’t too much to say. The south side is just a staircase and a level path, but all that’s down there is a cemetery and a bus connection to the 30 (the route is ridiculously infrequent, so it doesn’t really matter that the stop is just a few signs). The north side is only a path, but it also has a bunch of bike racks, a nice touch. I have to say, though, that the crosswalk across Baltimore Ave up here can be treacherous at rush hour. I kinda wish the intersection had “beg lights” that stop all traffic, because otherwise it feels like there’s never a safe time to cross.
Okay. For some reason, this station’s GTFS feed (the data that goes into transit applications like Google Maps) only has an entrance to the south. That means that if you’re trying to get directions from the north (i.e. the only section of station coverage that’s not occupied by a cemetery, i.e. the place where people actually live), Google Maps will not tell you to use this station. It will direct you to the next stop on the respective branches out of here. This is such mindblowingly bad implementation of GTFS, and it means that for most people using Google Maps to figure out how to get somewhere, this station will not be used. Wonderful.
Station: 40th Street Portal (Trolleys)
Ridership: SEPTA doesn’t care about its Subway-Surface Trolley stations, so I’m forced to rely on just my own two eyes for this one. It’s about as busy as you would expect for a trolley station – usually there’s at least one other person who gets off with me here (this being my home station), and there are often people going both outbound and inbound from here.
Pros: They’ve really done a great job with the gardens. The whole station is beautiful, the Trolley Car Station restaurant is a fantastic way to increase visitors here, and the actual waiting areas are pretty darn good. It’s a peaceful place to catch the trolley.
Cons: The pathways through here are an issue, but the GTFS is my biggest problem with this place. What better way to discourage ridership than to actively prevent Google Maps from being able to recommend its usage to people??
Nearby and Noteworthy: Most attractions on 40th Street are slightly closer to the El station a few blocks north, but places closer to the trolley station include Allegro Pizza and the charming House of Our Own bookstore. Also, the cemetery to the south looks like a nice place to walk around. At least Google Maps will actually tell you to use this station if you want to go there.
Final Verdict: 7/10
I really do like this station, and I commend everyone involved with its renovation for sticking out the eight years it took to plan and build everything. But man…that GTFS thing just kills it for me. It’s just so insane that Google Maps just won’t tell you to use this station, even if you’re coming from across the street from it. Sure, most people will see it and know to use it, but this blunder is only hurting ridership. It’s just so freaking stupid, and all it would take to fix is adding another entrance in the code. But SEPTA doesn’t do that for any station in its feed, so I guess that’s a non-starter. Really, though, other than that, I like this station quite a lot.
UPDATE 10/29/18: Does SEPTA read my blog? The GTFS error has been fixed! You can now “get” to the station from the north! Alright, let’s update the score to an 8/10, then!

Latest MBTA News: Service Updates
SRTA: FR 9 (Bedford Street)
What was my first impression of the 9? Well, I couldn’t really form one…because the bus never showed up! Sam and I got to the first stop five minutes early, but I guess that was a little too late – the rascal left before we got there. All was lost. We weren’t going to complete the system in a day. “No,” I declared. “You know what? Screw the 9. If it’s not going to dignify us with a ride, then let’s not do it.” So…we were going to drive the route.
We curved around onto Pleasant Street, which was lined with dense houses. At the awkward intersection between the FR 9 and the NB 9, we turned onto Eastern Ave, a wide road with a grassy median. It was still mostly residential, but we also went by a park. We eventually turned onto Bedford Street, starting an annoying jog – this would be weird to do in a car.
We turned onto Stonehaven Road, going by much more suburban houses than before, as well as the Diman Vocational Technical High School – I think that was the main reason for this deviation. We turned onto Locust Street next, then Oak Grove Ave, where the houses started to get denser. Once we got back onto Bedford Street, they were back to being quite dense, and businesses in between were appearing more and more often. That culminated in downtown Fall River, where we made our way around to the terminal…or just outside it, since cars aren’t allowed in the busway.
SRTA Route: FR 9 (Bedford Street)
Ridership: Wow…400 people per day in May 2014? That’s…way more than I would’ve thought! Then again, I did the route in a private car, so I really had no idea how many people the bus got. It does serve a lot of dense neighborhoods.
Pros: Like I said, the 9 serves a bunch of dense neighborhoods, and it has a good ol’ half-hourly schedule on weekdays.
Cons: First of all, for the ridership this route gets, I would expect half-hourly Saturday service (versus the current hourly schedule) and even Sunday service, as well as night service (right now the route ends at around 6 PM). Also, there has to be a layover point somewhere on this route! I mean, Pleasant Street at Eastern Ave (a little further from where I was trying to board) is technically the “start” of it, so maybe it lays over there? But knowing the SRTA, I’ll bet buses just leave whenever they arrive. That is unacceptable.
Nearby and Noteworthy: Houses, and some businesses that didn’t look too appealing. Yup.
Final Verdict: 4/10
Look, the bus left so early that I couldn’t even catch it. It’s probably more of a 5/10 route, but that fact alone is worth a point off. Probably should be more than one, but the 9 isn’t that bad otherwise. Darn it.
UPDATE: Turns out the ridership numbers for this route were accidentally copied over from the 10. The graph shows the real numbers, which are a lot more mediocre, around 150 people per day. Now the schedule makes more sense. Honestly…this is more like a 2/10, given the ridership, plus the earliness.
Latest MBTA News: Service Updates
27 (Broad-Carpenter – Plymouth Meeting Mall)
Ready to ride this express route from Plymouth Meeting Mall to Philadelphia? Ready to experience this super fast express ride into the city? Ready to travel down miles of local roads before running “express” on the infamously trafficked I-76? Yeah, that last one describes the 27 pretty well.
We made our way onto Germantown Pike from the Plymouth Meeting Mall, and we went through a complex series of interchanges between I-276 and I-476. We then turned onto Chemical Road, which led us under I-476 again before we performed a deviation into the Metroplex Center. Once we came back onto Chemical Road, it went under I-476 again – this would be our last interaction with that road.
We turned onto Ridge Pike, and after some SUBURBAN BUSINESS MADNESS, it transitioned to houses and apartment complexes…and a few golf courses. We proceeded along like this, slowly picking up passengers. The route also has a short-turn point along here at Church Lane where some trips begin or end their trips to Philly.
At some point we entered Philly, but it sure didn’t feel like it. We did arrive at Andorra and its shopping center soon after that, where we used Port Royal Ave to get onto Henry Ave. Still, there wasn’t much along here – it was basically houses and apartments on one side of the road and Wissahickon Valley Park on the other side. The houses did eventually become duplexes, continuing as we turned onto Leverington Road.
We turned onto Ridge Ave, which was actually an urban street lined with apartments and businesses, but it went back to houses once we took a right onto Lyceum Ave soon after. Again, that didn’t last long; it was urban again when we turned onto Manayunk Ave, although it was almost entirely apartments. We were up on a huge hill above Manayunk proper, so every side street was super steep.
We turned onto Ridge Ave once again, crossing over the Manayunk/Norristown Line tracks and passing Wissahickon Station. Once we got down the hill entirely, it was time for the Wissahickon Transportation Center, although we didn’t actually pull in like we’re technically supposed to. Finally, we made our way onto City Ave, crossing the Schuylkill River, and then it was time to merge onto I-76 for our express section.
In typical I-76 fashion, we went around a practically 90-degree curve, and soon after that was traffic. Darn it! We were stuck in that for a good while as the highway snaked along with the Schuylkill through Fairmount Park. Eventually, we broke out from the park to get a view of the train yards north of 30th Street Station, then we took Exit 344 onto I-676, the Vine Street Expressway.
The Vine Street Expressway is so named because it runs in an open cut underneath Vine Street, and it’s awful, and I hate it. Also, it too was jammed. Luckily, we weren’t on this for too long, as we took the exit onto 15th Street and then turned onto Broad. City Hall loomed ahead as the surrounding buildings got taller and taller.
We curved around City Hall on the surrounding streets before returning to Broad on its Avenue of the Arts section. Going by all of Philly’s major theaters, we proceeded down the wide road. Now, the 27 is interesting because it doesn’t actually end in Center City – it actually travels down Broad down as far south as Washington Ave. But past Walnut, I was the only one on board.
By the time we got to around Locust, the theaters and skyscrapers had simmered down to become smaller businesses and apartments. Interestingly, the route is shown as looping a certain way on the map (via Carpenter, 15th, and Washington), but we ended up looping via Christian, 11th, and Washington instead. Oh well, we made it to Broad and Carpenter either way…the driver seemed pretty surprised that I took the bus down this far.
Route: 27 (Broad-Carpenter – Plymouth Meeting Mall)
RIdership: Although the 27 has a pretty terrible farebox recovery ratio (15%) because of its length, 4,390 passengers per weekday is nothing to sneeze at. That ends up being about 32 people per one-way trip! My Saturday ride was even busier, with 49 passengers in total heading into Center City. Not everyone stayed on for the express (a particularly large amount of people got off at Wissahickon), but it was about a full-seated load heading into Philly.
Pros: The 27 takes a pretty logical path from the northwestern suburbs into the city, serving shopping plazas and dense neighborhoods (eventually) along the way. The route’s schedule is…interesting, but one thing I’ll say about it is that there’s a ton of service at rush hour – every 5-10 minutes or so. This is one of the few SEPTA routes that’s more productive in the peak than it is in the off-peak, so yay, the extra frequency is justified!
Cons: Once you leave rush hour, though, the route gets a lot less frequent. It’s every half hour, kinda, during the day, but the departure times are all over the place, and it’s sorta every 35 minutes on Saturdays, and it’s more or less every hour on Sundays. Granted, I get why the times are so crazy – I assume it has to do with the varying conditions on I-76. And that brings us to our next point: on-time performance! It’s terrible! I-76 is really crazy and unreliable! Basically, according to the numbers, the 27 is late 35% of the time. That’s not good.
Nearby and Noteworthy: This is honestly the fastest route from Center City to Manayunk if you don’t mind walking up or down a steep hill, but other than that, there’s not much. Just some malls.
Final Verdict: 5/10
It’s an unreliable express route that’s super long and should probably run more frequently than it does on weekends, based on the ridership I saw. On the other hand, it takes a really direct path to Center City from the places it serves, and the extra service during the peak is actually warranted. Clearly, there are really good things and really bad things about the 27, so let’s just plop its score right in the middle with a 5.
Latest SEPTA News: Service Updates
SRTA: FR 7 (Bay Street)
Believe it or not, the SRTA route with the most legit terminus is also one of the least frequent routes on the system. Yes, the 7 ends at a proper turn around, probably a remnant from an old streetcar! Yet it’s one of the few in-town routes that runs every hour on weekdays. Well, let’s see why that might be.
I’m not quite sure why, but the 7 has a jog up past I-195 on its outbound route. We went over the highway on 4th Street, then we used Troy Street to get to Bedford Street, passing some vacant downtown buildings and a post office. Soon after passing Main Street (where downtown is actually pretty nice), we turned onto Milliken Boulevard, crossing south over the highway again. What was the point of this jog when the inbound route doesn’t even do it? I have no idea. It was even worse when the outbound route would have a second deviation to Battleship Cove, but it’s not running right now because of construction.
We now turned onto Columbia Street, which was lined with dense houses and apartments, as well as some businesses. Columbia Street ended and we used the parking lot-filled Broadway to get to William Street. It became Bay Street as it curved south, and as the name suggested, we were rather close to Mount Hope Bay.
Bay Street was a bit of an odd one; on the bay side, it kinda switched between big industrial buildings and suburban houses. The inland side was just residential, with the occasional apartment development. We basically just sped past all this with no one on the bus until we hit the Bay Street Turn Around, just before the Rhode Island border. That was that!
SRTA Route: 7 (Bay Street)
Ridership: I’m impressed by how many people this route seems to get. It got 6,941 passengers in May 2014, which ends up being 257 per day, or around 10 per one-way trip. That’s pretty darn good for SRTA, and the total number is very close to and sometimes even higher than other, more frequent routes.
Pros: My trip only got one person, so I thought this route doesn’t get a lot of people, but it turns out it does! My guess is that some of those big apartment developments along Bay Street generate riders. Anyway, that’s what I like about it: it runs a fairly direct route down an important street in southwest Fall River.
Cons: Okay, we’ve established that the 7 gets similar ridership numbers to other SRTA routes…except the 7 is every hour on both weekdays and Saturdays when most others are at least every half hour on weekdays. It’s even a similar length to the other routes! If anything, raising the frequency to the level of other routes would generate even more ridership! Either run each route every hour or each route every half hour, because clearly, they’re getting similar amounts of people. Oh, also, that outbound-only deviation is stupid. Just had to put that somewhere.
Nearby and Noteworthy: I think the SRTA intends to have this route start serving Battleship Cove again once construction there ends. I’m not a fan of putting an even longer outbound-only deviation on this thing, but Battleship Cove does seem like a cool place.
Final Verdict: 5/10
I don’t get it. The hourly 7 gets higher ridership than at least one other route that gets half hourly weekday service. It’s a short route, so it would only take one more bus to improve service, and the way SRTA interlines, it would also improve service somewhere else. I dunno, I’m not a fan of this route double standard of sorts, especially since each trip on the 7 is going to get twice the passengers of other routes because it runs at half the frequency.
Latest MBTA News: Service Updates
90 (Plymouth Meeting Mall to Norristown Transportation Center)
There are two ways of getting from the Norristown Transportation Center to the Plymouth Meeting Mall. One is the 98, which is as reasonably direct as you would expect a suburban bus route to be. The other is the 90. It is a mess.
Well, the route starts out normal enough. We made our way onto Main Street, which was lined with dense businesses and apartments. Arriving at the very barebones Main Street Regional Rail station, we turned onto the wide Markley Street, using it to get onto Marshall Street. Now, it’s worth noting that we took this retail-lined road in the opposite direction of the mall, but…maybe there was a good reason for it.
The businesses turned to apartments, and the apartments turned to duplex houses when we turned onto Stanbridge Street. At this point, the route had been relatively normal, but once we turned onto Laurel Street, it was all over. This took us into the Norristown State Hospital campus, which consisted of winding, speed bump-ridden roads. Arghhhhhh.
I’ll spare you the twisty route we took through this campus, but good lord, it was excruciating. Like I said before, speed bumps were rampant, so it was a constant 15 miles an hour through the whole detour. The roads were also super narrow, so that made making turns a blast. Yeah, the Norristown State Hospital deviation was a great way to spend 8 minutes of my life.
We left the campus and turned onto Sterigere Street, which took us back to the original entrance point to the hospital. We continued on Sterigere from there, going over Stony Creek and merging onto Harding Boulevard, a wide road with a leafy median. Next, we turned onto Markley Street, a mere 7 minute walk from the last time we were on it. The bus ride, for the record, had been about 15 minutes.
Markley Street was mostly residential, and its dense apartments slowly turned into regular houses. There was a brief spurt of suburban businesses, and right after that, we entered East Norriton and the street became Swede Road. It was mostly houses until we got to the suburban retail of Germantown Pike. We did a slow deviation to “serve” a few shopping centers, which seemed pretty pointless considering that despite its pedestrian unfriendliness, Germantown Pike does have sidewalks and crosswalks.
Where would we go from the “East Norriton Crossing Shopping Center”? Would it be a left towards the mall? No, apparently not…we took a right instead. Suburban businesses gave way to suburban houses, which gave way to…farmland? Where the heck were we?
Oh, I see. It was a deviation to the Einstein Medical Center. Okay. Yeah. That’s nice. Cool. I’m glad this route goes out of its way to serve every single thing on the planet. What did we do from there? Head straight back, of course! Another ten minutes gone!
Finally, it was time to go to the mall. The rest of the route was on Germantown Pike, and it was smooth sailing. The road itself was a suburban smorgasboard of houses, retail, parking lots, random apartment buildings, and office parks. Suddenly, there was the mall, and we pulled in. That was that…thank goodness.
Route: 90 (Plymouth Meeting Mall to Norristown Transportation Center)
Ridership: The route gets 572 people per weekday, which divides out to around 17 people per trip. I guess that’s okay, but it is worth noting that this is the 11th lowest-ridership route in SEPTA’s Suburban Division.
Pros: If you want a tour of every hospital and mall in the Norristown area, this is the route for you! No, I’m kidding, but the 90 definitely does serve important places with its deviations that no other routes go to. It runs every hour six days a week, from about 6 AM to…11 PM? Wow, that’s late for a route like this!
Cons: If you’re trying to use this bus to get anywhere, tough luck! Even if you’re trying to get to one of its deviations, like the Einstein Medical Center, it will still take forever because you almost always have to suffer through another one, like the Norristown State Hospital deviation! Plus there’s the random deviation to the shopping plazas that doesn’t seem to have much of a purpose to me. Heck, why not just terminate the route at the Einstein Medical Center and let people bound for the mall take the 98? Seems like that would save some route miles. The routes are only about a 6 minute walk apart in Norristown, and they run right with each other on Germantown Pike.
Nearby and Noteworthy: Norristown Farm Park actually looks like an awesome place to walk around, so I guess that’s a bonus to the Einstein Medical Center deviation. This is also the closest route to the Elmwood Park Zoo, a quieter and slightly cheaper alternative to the Philadelphia Zoo. Taking the 90 is a whole six minutes faster than flat-out walking from the Norristown Transportation Center! Wow!
Final Verdict: 3/10
This is the kind of route I would expect to see in some tiny nowhere town, not a major Philadelphia suburb. I understand that the places the 90 serves are important, but because it has so many deviations serving different markets, the route ends up being more inefficient for everybody. Taking it from beginning to end, which no sane person should ever do, was a nightmare. Just use the 98 if you’re going to Plymouth Meeting!
Latest SEPTA News: Service Updates
SRTA: FR 3 (Laurel)
The 3 ends right around where the 5 ends, so let’s hop on that to get back into Fall River!
I actually got the 3 from Stop & Shop, since it’s an outbound-only deviation right near the terminus! It actually does another one just before the Stop & Shop to the Fall River Shopping Center, but they share a parking lot, so it’s technically the same deviation. From Stop & Shop, we looped our way around to the proper terminus at Ocean State Job Lot…but the layover point is kinda far from the store, so it feels like the bus is just sitting in a random industrial area instead.
So we went down Amity Street from the end (or now start) of the route, and the industry soon gave way to an apartment development. It turned to regular houses when we turned onto Laurel Street, but there also was another development and the back of the Fall River Shopping Center. From there, though, it was basically all houses until we got to Plymouth Ave.
We were on Plymouth Ave for exactly one block before we turned off onto Globe Street. This was an urban local street: dense houses and a few little businesses here and there. We turned onto East Main Street, which was more or less the same thing until we joined South Main Street, meeting up with the 1 soon after. Now, there were lots of businesses, as well as a hospital and a park. The road started to feel like a downtown eventually, with a ton of dense retail on both sides, and once we hit I-195, we made our way around to the terminal.
SRTA Route: FR 3 (Laurel)
Ridership: Overall ridership on the 3 is pretty good; in May 2014, it got about 365 passengers per day. It’s interesting to note, though, that the route got about 24 passengers per revenue hour – the 3 runs every half hour, so that’s four trips every hour (two in each direction), meaning an average of six people per trip. Hm.
Pros: The route takes a direct path to the southern parts of Fall River, and it serves some big important stores near its terminus. It’s also super frequent, running every half hour weekdays and Saturdays, although only until around 6 PM.
Cons: The terminus at Ocean State Job Lot is really weird, and there’s little indication of where the bus actually boards. I also wonder if there’s a market for night or Sunday service in the form of a 3/5 loop – that could be a more efficient way of providing it if it’s needed. Indeed, neither the 3 nor the 5 get that much ridership, so maybe they could be combined full-time.
Nearby and Noteworthy: Nothing much except for the shopping centers at the end of the route. I already mentioned the South Main Street corridor in the 1 review, but that looks interesting, too.
Final Verdict: 7/10
It’s a good local route. It’s direct. It serves places that need bus service. Not much else to say here, it’s not a very interesting route.
Latest MBTA News: Service Updates
97 (Chestnut Hill – Norristown Transportation Center)
I wasn’t exactly sure where I was going to go after getting dropped off from the 23 in Chestnut Hill, but lucky for me, there was a 97 leaving right when I arrived! I didn’t think I’d be going to Norristown that day, but the 97 turned out to be a strange suburban route that was super fun to ride.
Having travelled a huge length of Germantown Ave on the 23, it was time to complete the rest of the road here on the 97. It became abundantly clear that the “downtown” section of Chestnut Hill ends right at the bus loop, because proceeding west from there, it instantly got leafy and suburban. We passed the Chestnut Hill Hospital, but for the most part, we were going by very large houses surrounded by even larger yards. Welcome to Chestnut Hill!
We went by the Woodmere Art Museum, which is housed in a giant mansion. It became woods for a little while as Germantown Ave crossed over Wissahickon Creek and soon turned into Germantown Pike, signalling our entrance into the community of Lafayette Hill (part of Whitemarsh Township). Aside from a restaurant, an apartment complex, and Chestnut Hill College at the intersection with Northwestern Ave, all we could see were trees, with houses hidden behind narrow driveways. Oh, and there was a golf course.
We came into a “downtown” of sorts with some retail, including a little shopping plaza. There was a stretch of woods, houses, and apartment developments, then we entered another downtown similar to the last one. Here we turned onto Joshua Road, going by more houses and another golf course.
By the time Joshua Road ended, it was starting to get a little more industrial, with office parks popping up in the woods. We turned onto Cedar Grove Lane for a block, then we made a right onto Hector Street. It was still very corporate, but we were right next to the Spring Mill Regional Rail station, so some TOD apartments had been built here. We were now in Conshohocken, and though it went back to being residential, those residences were now dense urban row houses. It was a quick change.
Hector Street split into a one-way pair with neighboring Elm Street, but we stayed on Hector as the apartments got even closer together than they were before. After the street made a sharp curve, we turned onto Harry Street, then Stoddard Street. This brought us right alongside the Manayunk/Norristown Line Regional Rail tracks, as well as Conshohocken Station.
From the station we looped around onto Fayette Street via some quick turns. This uphill road was the main street of Conshohocken, so it was lined with a ton of different businesses. It got more suburban-feeling the further we went, though, and it turned into Butler Pike once we left Conshohocken. It was a hodgepodge of stuff now, from houses to auto shops to a cemetery.
There were a few big shopping plazas at the intersection with Ridge Pike, which we turned onto. This was pure suburban garbage, with a ton of random businesses, all with huge parking lots. Even better, it was time for a deviation! Turning onto the appealingly-named Chemical Road, we made our way up to the Metroplex Center, which is just a regular ol’ shopping center that’s a lot less amazing than it sounds.
After the deviation on the mall’s main road, we made quick turns onto Gallagher Road, 7 Stars Lane, and Alan Wood Road; on that last one, we passed the SEPTA Frontier Division depot! We turned back onto Ridge Pike, which had now morphed to be almost entirely car dealerships. Crossing I-276, the road then became Main Street as we entered Norristown.
There was industrial scenery for a while, but at some point, it almost instantly turned into dense row houses. Just as businesses were starting to come in, we turned onto Arch Street, then Airy Street. Among the various apartments, we also went by the Norristown Police Department and Post Office, as well as the huge Montgomery County Courthouse. It was at the courthouse that we turned onto Swede Street, and this took us straight down to our final stop at the Norristown Transportation Center.
Route: 97 (Chestnut Hill – Norristown Transportation Center)
Ridership: Although the route only gets an average of 790 passengers per weekday, that averages out to be about 22 per trip, which isn’t terrible. Believe it or not, my Saturday trip got exactly 22 passengers, so it seems like it stays reasonably stable on weekends.
Pros: Conshohocken isn’t an easy town to serve on an southeast-northwest route since it’s kind of out of the way, but the 97 takes a decent stab at it. It’s true that serving Conshy basically requires a giant deviation, but it’s definitely worth it – it’s a dense place. Indeed, the 95 and the 97 combine to provide service in all directions from Conshy, with the 95 going southwest to northeast. But what is the 97’s schedule like? It’s what you would expect: every hour, seven days a week. I think that’s reasonable for the environments the route travels through, plus it has a good span of service, from around 5 AM to midnight on weekdays.
Cons: Believe me, I will be complaining a lot about twisty SEPTA suburban routes. In the case of the 97, the Metroplex Center deviation is a little annoying, but I think it is warranted. Another minor problem of the route is that it has a bunch of short-turns that make things more confusing. Aside from the main destinations, the 97 can also begin or end at the Victory Division depot, Conshohocken Station, and Barren Hill, and they all happen at different times on different days (although only near the beginning and end of service). Even though they mostly make sense, it is making the service more complex.
Nearby and Noteworthy: I would say Conshy, but it’s a heck of a lot easier and faster to get there using Regional Rail. I guess if you’d rather make the trek up to Chestnut Hill on the 23 and transfer to this to get there, be my guest.
Final Verdict: 7/10
SEPTA has a lot of terrible suburban routes, but I don’t think this is one of them. It’s twisty for sure, but the deviations serve important places, so I get why they’re there. This may not be the most direct route if you happen to be going from Chestnut Hill to Norristown, but that’s not really the kind of trip the 97 is for.
Latest SEPTA News: Service Updates
SRTA: FR 5 (Stafford Road)
I didn’t think the SRTA actually makes it to Rhode Island, but I was wrong – the FR 5 very much enters that friendly small state to the south. As for the rest of the route? It isn’t all that interesting, alas.
We did a little loopy-loop coming out of the terminal, eventually making our way onto 4th Street. This was an extremely narrow road lined with dense houses, so it was a pretty big change when we suddenly merged onto the very wide Plymouth Ave. We weren’t on this for too long, though, as we soon turned onto Warren Street, another narrow road lined with dense houses.
We turned onto Lapham Street, another narrow road with the same scenery, but then we turned onto Brayton Ave, which was a rather wide road with…the same scenery. We then made a left onto Stafford Road, and after going down that for a bit, we performed a deviation into the Seabra Supermarket. It was only saving people about a two minute walk, but okay, whatever…
We passed a park as the houses started to get more suburban and spread out. There were also a few businesses thrown in at certain intersections. Just before crossing Route 24, we turned into the SouthCoast Marketplace (formerly known as Harbour Market, as seen on the bus’s headsign). This was a fancy new mall complete with a Market Basket and even a modern bus shelter!
This was also a well-executed deviation because we used the mall parking lot to get out to a new street, William S. Canning Boulevard. This wide road took us through an interchange with Route 24, and on the other side, we entered Tiverton, Rhode Island! We weren’t in it for long, though – after reaching a newly-constructed rotary, we looped onto Stafford Road, which took us back into Massachusetts. The route’s final stop was right on the border.
SRTA Route: FR 5 (Stafford Road)
Ridership: In 2014, the most recent year for which I could get ridership data, it seemed the 5’s ridership was on the decline. In May of that year, the route averaged around 308 riders per day, down from an average of 467 in May the previous year. I don’t know what things are like now, but the route’s schedule is near identical to what it was in 2014 (and, indeed, 2013), so the changing numbers seem to have been due to other factors.
Pros: The 5 serves important destinations in the southern portion of Fall River, and for SRTA standards, it’s reasonably direct and most of the jogs make sense. It also has great frequency, with service every half hour weekdays and Saturdays.
Cons: First of all, this route has no night service, which I think would be useful considering that both Seabra and SouthCoast Marketplace are open until 9 and 11 PM respectively. It would be helpful for a lot of people if service was extended past its current 6 o’clock ending. On the topic of Seabra Supermarket, I don’t think this really has to deviate in there when it’s such a close distance to the road, but that’s the only problematic detour. Finally, I’m skeptical of the terminus – it’s one of those SRTA termini that’s just a street stop, and as I would come to find out later, buses tend to leave early from those kinds of stops. Just be aware that vehicles might depart the terminus a few minutes ahead of schedule.
Nearby and Noteworthy: Nothing that would be interesting to outsiders, but Seabra and SouthCoast Marketplace are both important shopping locations for Fall River residents.
Final Verdict: 6/10
The 5 seems like a decent route, but it has enough problems to bring its score down to a 6. Does it really have to directly serve the front door of Seabra Supermarket? Wouldn’t it be beneficial if it had night service (or even Sunday service, although there are other routes that need it much more)? Don’t buses leave that terminal early a lot? It’s an important route, but it has issues.
Latest MBTA News: Service Updates
23 (Center City – Chestnut Hill)
This is it. This is the big one. Center City to Chestnut Hill. Over ten miles of local streets. A myriad of different neighborhoods, buildings, and demographics. Let’s do it: the 23.
As I mentioned in the last review, I chose Market Street as the transfer point between the 45 and the 23. The 23 actually begins a few blocks south on Locust Street, but very few people were on board when the bus arrived – Market was the big stop where lots of people got on. Once everyone was on, we took off down 11th Street, passing Jefferson Station and getting a glimpse of Reading Terminal Market a block away.
We went under the Hilton’s Convention Center Garage, but not the Convention Center itself, whose three-block long building ends at 11th. We were in Chinatown as we went over the horrible Vine Street Expressway, but that more or less ended once we went under the rail viaduct that might eventually become part of the Rail Park. Right after that was a huge electric substation where the 45 officially terminates.
As we crossed the wide Spring Garden Street, the neighborhood seemed to be in transition from old buildings in disrepair to brand new ones. The contrast continued as the scenery turned to row houses, until they got replaced by…duplex houses? What?? Okay, I guess there’s just a random suburban neighborhood in the middle of North Philadelphia. Sure.
After we crossed Girard Ave with its vintage streetcars, it went back to row houses, but the cul-de-sac street pattern within the grid suggested that these were built later in Philadelphia’s life. And then, suddenly, the buildings started to get taller and more modern. Yes, it was time to travel through Temple University with its high-rise dorms, huge classroom buildings, and sports fields.
The influence of the university more or less stopped once we went under the elevated Regional Rail tracks. Beautiful murals and gardens were set up next to the overpass, and there was a big park just after the crossing, but it was clear that we were starting to enter the heart of North Philadelphia. The buildings weren’t as well maintained, there were vacant lots in places, and everything generally felt more run-down.
Suddenly, we turned onto Huntingdon Street for a short time, then made a left onto Germantown Ave. This was a very different part of the neighborhood – a commercial thoroughfare, Germantown Ave was lined with colorful and unique businesses. It was still very much North Philadelphia (lots of discount stores and check-cashing places, for example), but this street was more vibrant, more bustling.
It turned back to apartments the further we went, though, and they were in pretty bad shape. Again, lots of vacant land between each building that was still standing, and the streetcar tracks in the middle of the road promised rail that may never come back. We went under the wide Northeast Corridor right of way, and on the other side, the apartments were supplemented by businesses, some industrial buildings, and a school. We also passed the modern Temple University Hospital.
Germantown Ave generally runs in a diagonal through the street grid, so eventually we were gonna hit Broad Street. We finally did with a huge intersection between Germantown, Broad, and Erie, and it was busy. There were tons of businesses, people walking around every which way, two sets of abandoned streetcar tracks (aside from the old 23 ones, the 56 on Erie was once a trolley, too), a very busy Broad Street Line stop, and lots of passengers getting on the bus.
Past that busy intersection, it went back to brick apartments, many of which had businesses on the first floor. A lot of the buildings were in disrepair, and a lot of the businesses were closed. We went over a railroad track, and though much of the retail was still closed, the buildings themselves started to be in better shape. There was another big change after we went under the Roosevelt Expressway and the apartments got more modern (like they were built in the past 10-20 years).

The buildings are definitely in better shape here (this is before crossing the Roosevelt Expressway).
We went under the complex system of railroad tracks next to Wayne Junction Station, and then, I’m very sad to say, we went on detour. The route would normally stay on Germantown Ave, passing various businesses of more or less the same ilk as before, albeit in more charming buildings. However, there was some sort of food festival going on, so we used Berkley Street to get onto Greene Street instead.
Greene Street was lined with apartments, but these were very different apartments from before; these ones were in great condition with big porches and gardens. We were now in the Germantown neighborhood, and it was clearly much different from North Philadelphia. At the Pennsylvania School for the Deaf, we turned onto School House Lane, using it to get back onto Germantown Ave, rejoining the regular route.
Clearly, Germantown Ave was still a major urban thoroughfare. It had gained lovely cobblestones since we left, but a lot of the retail along it was still closed. It didn’t seem like we were in a “nice” neighborhood yet, but we were getting closer. We passed a park, and as we continued along, a higher proportion of the retail became operational.

What appears to be a gorgeous old church (EDIT: Ira in the comments pointed out that this is Germantown’s old, beautiful, and vacant former town hall).
The number of historical sights also increased as we went on – we were going by a lot of historical societies and historic houses and whatnot. Indeed, it seemed like every building was a historical sight, especially combined with the cobblestoned road with trolley tracks in the middle! We went through a park past a historical mansion, and there were some rather large houses along the road for a bit.
The leafy road passed SEPTA’s Germantown District facility as the buildings continued to get more charming. It was distinctly urban again (back to apartments rather than houses), and now the businesses served very different purposes than what we had been seeing previously. No more discount stores or check-cashing places – now, there were playhouses, produce markets, and pet shops.
We passed a gigantic park that was part of a church, then we curved around past an old 23 PCC streetcar that had been converted into a diner. The street went under a disused rail right of way and past the start of a trail going into a really gigantic park, and now we were in Chestnut Hill. Yes…we had arrived in one of the richest urban neighborhoods in the country. This route really is dynamic. And it’s entirely within the boundaries of Philadelphia.
Chestnut Hill’s downtown was about as upscale as a downtown can be. Artist shops, clothing stores, and fancy restaurants were all prominent as we trundled down Germantown Ave through the neighborhood center. Once we passed Chestnut Hill West station, the bus turned into the Chestnut Hill Loop, and that was it. The end of a very interesting ride.
Route: 23 (Center City – Chestnut Hill)
Ridership: This used to be the busiest bus route on SEPTA, but once it was split off from the 45, it has now dipped to second busiest behind the 18, although it’s by a very small margin. The 23 gets an average of 17,672 riders per weekday (the 18 gets 17,760), which is a ton. Indeed, my Saturday morning ride going outbound got a total of 96 riders! Wow! The bus was never too busy at any given time, though, since the ons and offs were spread out along the whole route.
Pros: Well geez, it certainly serves a lot, huh? The 23 passes through so many different neighborhoods with so many different atmospheres and demographics, it’s like a tour of Philadelphia. You’ll also never have to wait long for a bus – the route runs every ten minutes or better on weekdays until around 8 (when it starts slowly making its way down to every half hour), every 15 minutes or better on Saturdays, and every 20 minutes or better on Sundays. It even has Owl service every 40 minutes all night, although only from Chestnut Hill to a little past Broad and Erie (facilitating transfers to the Broad Street Owl).
Cons: This is a long, slow route. For example, it’s scheduled to take about an hour on Saturdays, but my trip ended up being 70 minutes. The length of the route also translates to some serious bunching. I mean, I saw three buses in a row going the other way! This is with a 15 minute headway, remember! If SEPTA actually had free transfers, the far better place to split the route with the 45 would be at Broad and Erie, since then both routes would actually be of reasonable length, and passengers could hop on the Broad Street Line there. Heck, it would save time to use that from points northwest instead of the really slow bus on local streets! Just another argument for dropping the transfer fee, SEPTA. And by the way, I’d just like to mention again that my “free” transfer from the 45 to the 23 didn’t work on Key!!!!
Nearby and Noteworthy: There’s a ton of noteworthy stuff on this route! From attractions in Center City to Temple University to historic Germantown to posh Chestnut Hill, the 23 serves many different parts of Philly. There’s something here for everyone.
Final Verdict: 6/10
It’s a really important and busy route…but it’s so darn long. It’s one of the most consistently frequent routes on SEPTA…but it’s so darn unreliable. There are a lot of tradeoffs with the 23, and I think a 6 captures the love/hate relationship that I (and everyone else who rides this thing) has with it. Even though it was a fantastic tour of Philly’s many neighborhoods (especially combined with the 45), I was definitely ready to get off the bus once I arrived up at Chestnut Hill…
Latest SEPTA News: Service Updates
SRTA: FR 4 (Robeson Street)
Sam and I had an ambitious plan to ride the entire rest of the SRTA in one day. How would we do that? He would drive me from route to route! We began this interesting and busy day with an early trip on the FR 4…
The route began at the Catholic Memorial Home, a nursing home in northern Fall River. From there, we headed down Highland Ave, which was lined with suburban houses. We stayed on it as it curved southwest in order to serve the Highlands Apartments, but then it was a turn onto the narrow Dexter Street to get onto Robeson Street, the route’s namesake road.
This was lots and lots and lots of houses until we suddenly did a jog onto Stanley Street. This was to serve both Truesdale Clinic and an apartment complex called President Village. The long jog took us via Ray Street and President Ave before we could get back onto Robeson Street. Upon our return, it was more houses, but they were denser now.
Although it was mostly residential, businesses were becoming more common. Once we turned onto Bedford Street, there were a ton of them, although many were industrial in character. Now in downtown Fall River, we turned onto 3rd Street, going by the City Hall over I-195, and from there, it was just a few twists and turns before we arrived at the Fall River Terminal…8 minutes early.
SRTA Route: FR 4 (Robeson Street)
Ridership: It looks like the 4 got about 234 people per day in 2014. That’s not great. Indeed, my early Saturday trip only had two people in total. I guess most of the route is residential and relatively suburban, so the lower ridership makes sense.
Pros: It’s a reasonably direct route that serves a big chunk of Fall River. It also runs surprisingly frequently, with service every half hour on weekdays and every hour on Saturdays. Service ends at around 6 PM, which I don’t think is a huge deal because of the suburban nature of the route.
Cons: The jog to Truesdale Clinic is a little annoying, but I get why it’s there, and this route is generally direct other than that. But…8 minutes early to the terminal? That’s a little scary. It seems like they pad the schedule between Truesdale Clinic, the previous timepoint, and the terminal, so at least it doesn’t seem to leave early from timepoints.
Nearby and Noteworthy: Eh…just a bunch of houses.
Final Verdict: 7/10
Yeah, this is a nice route. It just does its thing, running up and down Robeson Ave. I wonder if it was running every half hour in 2014 when the ridership data was taken or if that happened after – if it happened after, I’ll bet the route gets much more ridership now.
Latest MBTA News: Service Updates

















































































































